Proposal: Launching Harmony’s Bitcoin Strategic Reserve (BSR) in January 2025

Its not explained in detail where the BTC reserve will be used but i assume would be almost 100% or 100% for Harmony Team to pay systems and Devs

I fully expect now that Harmony know how to make a USDT/USDC reserve on a bull market, being that this BTC will be mainly for them if a bear market hits hard on ONE why this proposal exist at all when Harmony could build its own reserve themselves in parallel with USDT/USDC?

No increased recovery time and after being done all 25% back to delegators while Harmony maintain its own BTC reserve and stability,

Also, on Signatory Composition who’s the 7 for the 5/7 ? I only count 6 on that. and 4/5 don’t scream security when 50% of the vote is from the same who made the proposal. Too low of confirmations for this “btc treasure” reserve, i would not expect any less than 10 and also having various old validators in there to confirm any transaction for this level of responsibility

in a nutshell, why this proposal is needed when Harmony could be doing it and have the same PR result without slowing down recovery and in the future the 25% back to delegators? :roll_eyes:

Edit: If the intended help is really all network (helping validators pay its servers included) and Harmony Team then i still maintain that’s to low requirement of signatures and that current validators are responsible to do now its own btc or usdt reserve on a bull market to maintain its own validator operation on a rash bear market instead of delaying the recovery and on its end the 25% back to delegators

3 Likes

Stop these hopium posts that are filled with untrue statements. Can we just keep going on with the conversation and proposal definition instead of these empty sentences?

Our meagre 5% cbBTC buys would not even be a blimp for coinbase, stop spreading misinformation about the potential listing.

Thanks in advance

2 Likes

The ‘Harmony backed by Bitcoin’ claim is also untrue. How is it backed? Like by what mechanism?

1 Like

Poll Results: Harmony Strategic Bitcoin Reserve (HSBR)

Validator Poll Results

  • Total Votes: 34
    • 74% Yes
    • 26% No

Community Poll Results (𝕏)

  • Total Votes: 186
    • 83.3% Yes
    • 16.7% No

Proposal Timeline

  1. :ballot_box: 11/20:
  • First poll on 𝕏 concluded with 54.1% “YES” to allocate 50% for buying Bitcoin.
  • Prompt: “Should we monthly allocate a % to the Harmony Bitcoin Strategic Reserve (HSBR)?”
  1. :white_check_mark: 11/20:
  • Proposal added to the Talk Forum to position Harmony for long-term strength and alignment with strategies like MicroStrategy’s.
  1. :white_check_mark: 12/7:
  • Harmony Recovery ONE officially proposed the establishment of the Bitcoin Strategic Reserve (BSR), scheduled to begin in January 2025, with a focus on acquiring Bitcoin.
  1. :white_check_mark: 12/17:
  • Polls conducted for both validators and the broader community, reinforcing strong support for the HSBR initiative.
1 Like

As per the feedback: “We should have continued through V1,2,3,4,5,6,7 until it’s a rock-solid proposal.” – Fortune Validator.

We will work to make the proposal better.

2 Likes

R1 is taking a step back and pausing on Version 3 of the Harmony Strategic Bitcoin Reserve. Based on recent feedback, we understand that adding another burn partner for the reserve could dilute recovery efforts, create links to the RMC, and would require a governance vote.

In the meantime, we want to highlight a validator who has stepped up in response to this feedback. This validator leads by example: Kratos has launched a validator where :100:% of the staking $ONE rewards will be dedicated to acquiring #Bitcoin and HODLing for the long term. It’s a fantastic initiative that supports Harmony in “Embracing the ₿itcoin Standard.”

Great work, Kratos! :clap:

Check it out here:
Harmony Validator - KRATOS 2.0

1 Like

It would be great to see Harmony delegating its $ONE treasury again to support initiatives and projects that have validators and are “Building on Harmony”!

3 Likes

Great to see the step back from R1 on a poorly defined plan and risky endevaour
Nah, not a fan of this. This BSR example has:

  1. 0 alignment for onchain DEFI
  2. What have you (or kratos) exactly build that should be supported by the core team?
  3. Kratos will be buying the BTC, therefore imposing a risk for the core team since they do not have access
  4. This new validator doesn’t reward it stakers with BTC (atleast isn’t stated anywhere…) so what will stakers/users benefit from?
1 Like

Thank you for your feedback, 4MCrypto. Constructive criticism like yours helps promote transparency and ensures alignment with the community’s expectations.

At R1, our priority is to facilitate and promote community-led solutions that strengthen the Harmony ecosystem.

We agree that Kratos needs to provide more details to address these questions.

We deeply value your input and will continue advocating for greater clarity, accountability, and transparency. Thank you for raising these important points!

1 Like